Mequoda Daily

Helping Publishers Make Money Online

Don Nicholas, Kim Mateus, and Amanda MacArthur

Hosted by Don Nicholas,
Amanda MacArthur and
Kim Mateus

Be a more confident, successful publisher in just five minutes each week!

Sign up to receive the Mequoda Daily, a free email newsletter with valuable case studies on:

  • Breakthrough Internet Strategies for Authors and Publishers
  • Proven Internet Marketing Sources, Programs and Tactics
  • Tips and Techniques for Designing More Effective Websites

And get Don Nicholas' valuable, free Special Report: Seven Online Publishing Secrets absolutely free.

Email Address:

Take The Mequoda Daily Order Button Color Quiz!

Executive Summary

  • Order button color can have a significant impact on response
  • A large publisher with hundreds of information products ran a big test
  • Be among the first 10 readers to post the winning order button color and I'll send you an Amazon Gift Certificate absolutely free!

Like Alias' Jack Bristow, "I've been trying to have more fun." I suspect you may need a little more fun in your life, too. With that in mind, I thought we could do a little reader participation contest today.

The Test: A large publisher was using a fire-engine red order button with white letters (see order button #1) throughout his online store. The site had a very clean blue and gold color scheme with a white background and black type. Full color product shots were available for all products.

He had read that "response red" was the order button color that would draw the highest response rates. Being a guy that would test everything, conventional wisdom be damned, he decided to test the three alternate order button color combinations (red/white, green/white, yellow/black, orange/black) shown below:

Option Aorder buttons
Option Border buttons
Option Corder buttons
Option Dorder buttons

Results: The test was run for a full week with order button click-through for all four versions in the thousands. Compared to the loser, the winner increased response and revenues by 27 percent.

Post your answer with a brief explanation. I'll post the actual results of the test next Friday. If you've run a similar test, post a brief run down of your test and the results. If you'd just like to make an educated guess, go for it!

Bonus: The first ten posts to identify the winning order button color will receive an Amazon Gift Certificate—plus my eternal gratitude and respect.

Lessons: Fun is good; and some things in life really are free!

Mequoda Library Members Only: For in-depth reporting on Website Design visit the Website Design for Publishers and Authors TOC page, or check out these related reports:

MeansBusiness.com Website Design Review, by Terri Edmonston
How to Design and Test for Common Sense: Navigation Affordance and Labeling, by Roxanne O'Connell
BlueDolphin.com Website Design Review, by Kim Mateus
LendingTree.com Website Design Review, by Roxanne O'Connell
Regional Newspaper Website Design, by Roxanne O'Connell

Other Resources

Note: As always, the details of the case have been modified to protect the identity of the publisher and their program. Void where prohibited by law or any other buzz kill. Mequoda Group, LLC is an Amazon.com Associate.

COMMENTS

The green button had to be the winner. It's the universal understanding that "green means go"

Comment by: Kathy R | September 16, 2005

The gold button... because Amazon uses it, and they are pretty smart about such things. OK, thats not a great explanation, but I can also confirm that it appeals to me the most of the 4 buttons. Yet I would never let the color of the button decide whether or not I buy something.

Comment by: Nikhil P | September 16, 2005

The darker yellow button has to be the winner. Yellow jumps out at the reader and asks for attention.

Comment by: Paul S | September 16, 2005

Option C, black on yellow because of its legibility.

Comment by: Mark S | September 16, 2005

The yellow (option C) version. It seems yellow is associated with the highest call to action.

Comment by: Debra P | September 16, 2005

I'll say green just because it jumps out at me the most. What appeals to ME is usually NOT the right answer but what the heck -- it's a guess.

Comment by: J T | September 16, 2005

Orange button (option D).

Comment by: Carol P | September 16, 2005

Option "C" is my pick. It catches my attention much better than the others.

Black or a dark color on a yellow (or greenish yellow) is the best contrast for the human eye to detect. That is my reason for thinking the yellow button was the winner.

Looking forward to the seeing the real results. This is good information. Thanks for doing the research.

Jerry Minchey www.SearchEngineU.com

Comment by: Jerry M | September 16, 2005

I go with C, yellow with black type. While I see a lot of red buttons, my guess is that the bulk of those have not been tested.

Besides the color, did he test the copy? That is where I have seen the big jumps in response rate.

Comment by: Stuart J | September 16, 2005

I think it was the green one. I don't have a theory as to why. That one just looks like the one I would click.

Comment by: Jason W | September 16, 2005

Option C: Yellow, easy to read and eye-catching. Red would stop me.

The green might be a possibility because it usually means go in traffic.

Comment by: Maritza L | September 16, 2005

My guess is that the green button on the white background increased response. White works better than black as a background color and green is both the color of money ("oh, I have to pay now...") and its use is still somewhat novel, so it likely jumps out to readers. BTW, the Mequoda Summit was very valuable...a great experience overall!

Comment by: John F | September 16, 2005

I vote for option "C", yellow/black

I'm not sure that I can explain why, but I think it is less intimidating to view, it is high contrast (black on yellow), and many of the "big gun" sites on the Internet use yellow as the background color for interactive boxes (so people would be used to or comfortable with this combination.

Interesting discussion - after all, why should a button color have any affect on someone's buying decision? It must be that some folks teeter back and forth on whether they should push the button or not . . . and if they feel less threatened then they justify going forward.

Steve

Comment by: Stephen B | September 16, 2005

I vote for Green! Says "go ahead"...

Comment by: Patricia S | September 16, 2005

I vote for green. It does say "go" to me. It also was my immediate gut feeling and I like to "go" with those. Can't wait to see the result.

Comment by: Casey D | September 16, 2005

Option D.

The green is pretty but fades into the background. Red is overdone. It could be yellow, but the gold looks classier -- while still grabbing attention.

Comment by: Marlene J | September 16, 2005

Option D, stands out but not excessively

Comment by: Ed C | September 16, 2005

My guess is that the GREEN button would generate more sales.

Many purchases on the Net are generated via impulse buying (awareness is less), so keeping all doors open for the buyer generates more sales. Any negative barriers like 'the price' are actually felt more strongly than the positive reasons for purchasing (Reaearch on brain imaging studies illustrate this). So it is imperative to keep the negative barriers to a minimum.

The color green is used worldwide in traffic signals and represents "Go". This would be noted unconsciously by the user and would in some cases provide that last little bit of incentive for the purchase. Obviously, following this logic, the color 'Red' represents "Stop". For purchasers who are a little unsure, this would be a final disincentive.

Comment by: Suzanne L | September 16, 2005

Option C. I think it is more inviting than the others. However, I leave nothing to chance and would test this type of thing too.

Comment by: Martin I | September 19, 2005

Option C. Not only is the black on yellow contrast more legible. The yellow has the highest contrast and visibility against the white background.

Comment by: Hugh R | September 19, 2005

It has to be option C because the color contrast is strongest.

Check out this link for a colorblindness test result:

http://colorfilter.wickline.org

Option C had the most contrast.

I don't think it's a fair test of "red" vs. "green" vs "orange" etc.. buttons, because the contrasting text is different on all of them Using simple words like "red button" doesn't really get to the level of detail that our eyes can - and sometimes can't - see.

Comment by: Terri E | September 21, 2005

Hi Everyone:

Thanks for all the feedback.

Option D, the Orange and Blue button is the big winner.

The full results:

Red and White: Index = 100 Green and White: Index = 114 Yellow and Black: Index = 122 Orange and Blue: Index = 127

My theory: Because blue is the coldest and orange is the warmest of all the colors, when combined they result in a unique combination of high contrast that is also highly balanced and complementary to the human eye.

For more information on color theory, check out:

http://www.cyber-prof.com/mdia1194/Lesson%203/lesson3-color-wheel.htm and http://www.ficml.org/jemimap/style/color/wheel.html

Note that opposites on the color wheel offer the highest visual contrast.

Our four winners will receive Amazon gift certificates early next week.

Thanks again to everyone who participated.

Don

Comment by: Don N | September 26, 2005

The green button.

Comment by: Gina H | December 20, 2005

The green one wins. Simply because we're programmed to go ahead with green, rather than any other colour.

Comment by: Sean D | December 20, 2005

Definitely yellow/black--it stands out the most.

Comment by: Holly K | January 3, 2006

Hi -- This is probably not the place to do this, but I can find no other way to get this info to you. Although my name and password are recognized on certain pages of the Mequoda site, other pages give me a Failed Logon message. When I press the Customer Service or Contact links, they take me back to the Failed Logon page. So I could get to SOME of your pages, but when I go deeper into the site, I get the Failed Logon. I am assuming that my membership is at the one year level now, as my debit card showed the 147 dollar charge recently. -- Can you be of any help here? -- Thank you and Take Care, David Scott Lynn -- dsl@dslbodymind.com is my log in e-mail address

Comment by: David L | February 8, 2006

Green

Comment by: Maritza L | March 24, 2006
ADD YOUR COMMENTS

Share Your Comments On This Story!

If you have comments about this story and want to post them on this page to share your thoughts with other readers, simply enter your comments below.


Hello Guest.

Write Your Comment
(Offensive materials and/or spam will be removed, no HTML allowed)

Please Note: Your signup must be verified via email before your comment is published. Comments are limited to 500 characters.

 Notify me when new comments are posted?

Hello Guest! | Log in

Increase text size: A A A

Topics
Free Special Reports
Resources

SUBSCRIBE!

Sign up to receive tips daily!
Your email:

We value your privacy

Upcoming Events

MEQUODA SUMMIT
BOSTON 2008


Join Don at:
SIPA's 25th Annual Mid-Year Marketing Conference: Gain. Market. Share.
December 8-10th, 2008
Mequoda Summit Boston 2008
Oct 14-15, 2008


Join Kim at:
SIPA's 25th Annual Mid-Year Marketing Conference: Gain. Market. Share.
December 8-10th, 2008
Mequoda Summit Boston 2008
Oct 14-15, 2008


Join Amanda at:
Mequoda Summit Boston 2008
Oct 14-15, 2008


RSS Feeds

Subscribe
Google Reader or Homepage

Add to My Yahoo!
Subscribe with Bloglines
Subscribe in NewsGator Online

BittyBrowser
Add to My AOL
Subscribe in Rojo
Subscribe in FeedLounge
Add to Technorati Favorites!
Add to netvibes
Subscribe in myEarthlink

Join us on Facebook:

Blogroll
.
ga-n